Thursday, September 16, 2010

"A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall" / Edie Brickell / Born on the Fourth of July Soundtrack

In high school in the late 80's, every girl I was friends with, and I mean EVERY girl, loved Edie Brickell. The Shooting Rubberbands at the Stars CD was a musical female Bible; she was the patron saint of the thoughtful, disaffected, moody teenage girl. Diaries, classroom folders and yearbooks had scribbled lyrics from "Circle". She just seemed to capture the zeitgeist of what it meant to be a adolescent girl back then.

And I'm not gonna lie, it wasn't too bad. Edie was easy on the eyes, and the music was nice when one was in the mood for some mellow tunes. I actually really liked the single "Mama Help Me" off of her follow-up album, but that was a litle bit darker and less accessable and didn't prove to be much of a hit. Then Brickell went on to marry Paul Simon, have some guiar stumming folkie babies, and was hardly heard from again(save the odd release).

In 1989, at the height of Brickell's popularity, the Tom Cruise war film Born on the Fourth of July was released. The soundtrack contained Brickell's perfect cover of this Bob Dylan song.

Here's the thing about Dylan: at the rick of losing any musical credentials I may have among people and alienating my Dylan-worshiping in-laws, I'm just really not a fan. I recognize his significant cultural impact, I appreciate his skill as a songwriter, but the perfomance just has never done it for me. The sloppiness of the music, the inscrutable, pretentious lyrics, that voice (though this is coming from a dude whose favorite band is led by Geddy Lee, so take it with a grain of salt), it's never worked for me.

Now songs that are Dylan covers I generally like. Of course, there's Hendix's "All Along the Watchtower" (considered by many to be the greatest cover of all time); I just recently heard a cover of "Girl From the North Country" by Lions on Sons of Anarchy - an incredible song that I downloaded before I even realized it was a Dylan cover, and there's this Brickell cover here. Dylan can compose a hell of a song, but his performance just leaves something to be desired.

I've never heard the original of this song, and it's probably just as well, because I always listen to this without any preconceptions or comparisons. It made sense once I found it out, though, as you can recognize some classic Dylan elements such as the wordiness, the odd imagery, the symbolism and the folk structure.

Brickell's gorgeous voice probably gives the song the biggest improvement. My favorite part of the song is the very beginning with the strummed intro and her crystal-clear tone lulling

Oh where have you been, my blue-eyed son?
Oh where have you been, my darling young one?


(And check out the chord change on the second "one" there - what a great punch, and it's repeated throughout the song)

The first verse is just Edie and the guitar, which is nice, but it's best just to ignore the lyrics about misty mountains, sad forests and dead oceans. I mean, I consider myself pretty well versed in poetic devices and symbolism, but come on. After the chorus, she adds more instrumentation, which makes the drop back to just her voice and the guitar very effective at the beginning of the third verse (3:03).

After that, I love the slow build from quiet to loud as Brickell takes advantage of the "Where the...." refrain which is repeated over and over and builds tension and intensity, finally dropping it off at 4:27, (on the word "sinking"). Finally, a really nice job with the false ending, "I'll know my song well before I start singing" and trailing off with a false ending at 4:34 before poping out with the chorus once more, and I just love how she belts that bad boy out - I still get chills when she hits the "Raaaaaain" high note at the end of the song.



Here's Dylan's version

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cheap and trendy deisgner clothing from ronkaclothing.com where we sell: Vitamin A Gold/White, Cossabella, Lizzie Fortunato Jewels, Morrell Maxie, Blouse, Non Denim, Holiday Dresses, Leggings, Classique, Made Her Think, Voom by Joy Han, Books and Games, http://www.eicop.org/m-682-nollie.aspx, Jessica Simpson, Textile Junkie, Hosiery, Thatcher by Alisse Thatcher, Manoush, Tori Praver Swimwear, Emotionally Unavailable, £50 - £100, Citrine by the Stones, Bridal Dresses, Tart, Amanda Uprichard, Coclico Shoes, Mini Dresses, LD Tuttle, Mighty Fine T- Shirts, Karen Walker, Dress, J.W. Hulme Co., Jenny Bird, Shrugs, Tube Top, Sherri Hill, ABS, Baby Bags, Business Accessories Business Electronic Travel Accessories, Janique, Alexander Wang, Wildfox Jeans, Tibi, Nika, Gypsyz, Hollywood Trading Company, Moni Moni, Cynthia Dugan Jewelry, Foley + Corinna, Twenty8Twelve, Sophomore, Evening Dresses, Nicole Miller Handbags, Mommy Tags, YARNZ, Jewelry, Splendid, Twelfth Street by Cynthia Vincent, Dina Bar-el - all available from our online designer clothing store at 50% off sale! Check out http://arts.harvard.edu - harvard university arts and fashion.
We admire work of Harvard University Arts and Fashion - best school of arts where great designers learn
how to create great looking designer clothing!

amybolsas5 said...

burberry bolsas
chanel bolsas
chloe bolsas
porte cles louis vuitton
boucle chanel
dior bolsas
sac dolce gabbana
sac fendi
sac guess
sac guess 2012
sac gucci
tee shirts armani hommes
tee shirts burberry femmes
tee shirts chanel femmes
sac guess
dolce gabbana bolsas
ed hardy bolsas
fendi bolsas
gucci bolsas
guess bolsas
dior tasche
sac a main
tee shirts
ceinture en cuir
jeans
lunettes de soleil
chaussures nike
chaussures puma
chaussures louis vuitton
porte cles chanel
bracelet louis vuitton

郭富城 said...

台灣威而鋼專賣店,威而鋼,台灣威而鋼專賣店,犀利士Cialis,威而鋼Viagra,陽痿,犀利士重現雄風,植物偉哥,金蒼蠅,偉哥,Viagra,cialis,Levitra,樂威壯,犀利士,壯陽藥品草本推薦,催情,犀利士大怒神,催情藥,犀利士炮炮到天明,迷姦藥,壯陽藥,壯陽藥那裡買,陰莖增大,陰莖增長,印度神油,金槍不倒,威而鋼哪裡買,蒼蠅水,壯陽,催情粉,催情水,犀利士床上叫不敢,犀利士男人救世主,早洩治療,陽痿治療,早洩剋星,春藥網,春藥,